“One could argue that Bo Donaldson and The Heywoods were not a not a one hit wonder band because of the song “Who Do You Think You Are,” (ClassicRockHistory.com). “The song became the band’s second top 20 hit of their career, thereby kicking them out of the one-hit wonder category. (The track) reached all the way up to number 15 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1974. Its chart success was fueled by their previous hit “Billy Don’t Be A Hero.” The song was written by Des Dyer and Clive Scott. It was originally recorded by the group Candlewick Green in 1973.”
On balance, “WDYTYA” generated a much more positive reaction for the Cincinnati-based band than “Billy Don’t Be a Hero” did. Rolling Stone reports in its 2011 Readers’ Poll “10 Worst Songs of the 1970s” that “U.K. pop group Paper Lace wrote ‘Billy Don’t Be A Hero’ at the tail end of the Vietnam War, but it’s actually about the American Civil War. But much like M*A*S*H was about the Korean War but really about Vietnam, people will forever associate ‘Billy Don’t Be A Hero’ with Vietnam. They’ll also associate it with insipid 1970s drivel. Paper Lace were planning on releasing the song in America, but Bo Donaldson and the Heywoods beat them to it.” Was the tune’s fife-and-drum intro also a tip of the hat towards the growing US Bicentennial history trend? Anyone’s guess.
In any case, it’s not hard to consider Donaldson’s second hit as a bit of a step up from the band’s first hit — and quite a bit easier on the ears. Starting in G Dorian, the tune shifts to C# major at 1:01. Led by a sitar-centric hook, it’s back to the original key for the next verse at 1:23.
