Author: Mod of the Day

The Phantom of the Opera (from “The Phantom of the Opera”)

For the second and final installment of our series marking the closing of Phantom of the Opera on Broadway, we feature the title song. Immediately defined by the iconic descending chromatic scale on the organ at the beginning, the tune also has many key changes scattered throughout. Beginning in D minor, it moves to G minor at 1:08 for the second verse and E minor at 1:48 for the third. There is another shift to F# minor at 2:48, followed by G# minor at 3:04 where it remains till the end.

The Choir | It’s Cold Outside

“The Choir was a garage rock band largely active in the greater Cleveland (Ohio) area from the mid-1960s into the early 1970s. Originally called the Mods, their largest commercial success came with the release of their first single ‘It’s Cold Outside’ in December 1966. The song (is) considered to be a classic of the garage rock era … The Choir is well known for containing three of the four original members of The Raspberries (all except lead singer Eric Carmen).”

A Cleveland Scene interview with one of the band’s members, Randy Klawon, details the city’s surprisingly active music scene during the late 1960s: ” … We played a show with the Who at the Music Hall in 1967. It was Herman’s Hermits and the Who. We were on that bill. I was 12 feet in the wings from [guitarist] Pete Townshend. I saw [drummer] Keith Moon throw his kit into the orchestra pit. It was amazing. Everybody saw the Beatles on Ed Sullivan. As these bands toured America, the Choir was on a lot of those shows. We were on the same bill with the Dave Clark Five and the Yardbirds and all kinds of bands.”

“It’s Cold Outside” starts in D major and shifts up to E major at 2:04.


Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again (from “The Phantom of the Opera”)

Andrew Lloyd Webber’s musical The Phantom of the Opera ended its record-setting 35-year Broadway run at the Majestic Theatre this past weekend, so this week we are going to feature two songs from the score. “Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again” is sung by Christine in Act 2 at her father’s grave as she looks for solace and advice. The song passes between G minor and G major for the first two verses and choruses, and then modulates up to Bb for the last chorus at 2:36.

Antonin Dvořák | String Quartet in F Major (Op. 96, B. 179, “American”), movement I: Allegro ma non troppo (Dover Quartet)

“In 1892, the American philanthropist Jeanette Thurber persuaded Czech composer Antonin Dvořák to head her newly formed National Conservatory of Music in New York City for three years, (MusicProgramNotes.com) … “Within a year, Dvořák had composed his Symphony in E-Minor ‘from the New World,’ … Directly after composing the ‘New World’ Symphony, Dvořák took a long summer holiday in 1893 in Spillville, Iowa … Amidst nature and his countrymen, Dvořák overflowed with musical ideas. Within three days he sketched out his entire String Quartet No. 12, later nicknamed the ‘American‘ … There is no movement without a gorgeous melody, and equally enticing are their delightful accompaniments … The American is unreservedly a masterpiece and crowd pleaser.”

The Guardian, placing Dvořák in his overall historic context: “As well as raising American consciousness of its Native American and African American traditions – a stance seen by some as vindicated by the emergence of jazz – Dvořák influenced a new generation of Czech composers, whose work was even more implicitly nationalistic. He befriended the young Janáček, who would eventually develop his music differently, but his mentor’s example was crucial. Dvořák also influenced his violinist and composer son-in-law, Josef Suk, who in turn briefly taught Bohuslav Martinů. Martinů’s assessment of Dvořák said it best: ‘If anyone expressed a healthy and happy relationship with life, it was he.’”

The quartet’s first movement begins in F major and features many side-steps into other keys, but an A major section starting at 1:38 is particularly striking.

Rhetta Hughes | Best Thing You Ever Had

” … soul vocalist Rhetta Hughes seemed about ready to move into the spotlight in 1969, when her remake of the Doors’ ‘Light My Fire’ made the R&B Top 40,” (AllMusic). “But she never sustained any momentum, with the next song ‘Angel Man’ flopping for Aria, and Hughes was soon back on the supper club circuit, opening for such comedians as Bill Cosby.”

AllMusic didn’t quite catch all of Hughes’ resumé, which included substantial musical theatre. She was featured in Dreamgirls, Amen Corner, Paris Lights, and other productions on Broadway, national tours, and off-Broadway. She was also nominated for a 1984 Tony award for Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Musical in Amen Corner, according to Broadway World.

“Best Thing You Ever Had” (1968) features multiple textbook half-step modulations, starting at 0:35. Others follow at 1:07 and 1:39.

The Bangles | In Your Room

“Bangles lead singer Susanna Hoffs wrote ‘In Your Room’ (1988) with Billy Steinberg and Tom Kelly, who have written many hit songs, including ‘Like a Virgin,’ ‘True Colors’ and ‘I Touch Myself,'” (Songfacts). Steinberg: “‘Right from the get-go, the Bangles were a retro ’60s kind of band. They loved ’60s music … They liked everything from Petula Clark to The Beatles, so when we got together to write with Susanna, it was right up our alley, because Tom and I grew up with ’60s music and that was what we loved also.’ The tune was written in the same batch of songs that produced ‘Eternal Flame,’ which was a #1 hit for the Bangles.” The tune was a #5 pop hit in the US and reached #35 in the UK.

The band’s distinctive mix of ’80s pop and playful ’60s psychedelic filigree is in full force here (to say nothing of the video’s visual references). An unprepared half-step modulation hits at 1:43.

Independently Owned (from “Shucked”)

“Independently Owned” is from the new Broadway musical Shucked. Composed by first-time musical theatre writers Brandy Clark and Shane McAnally, the song is performed in the show by Lulu (played by Alex Newell), shown here recording the track for the cast album. Not only does the tune have a modulation, but Lulu announces it while she’s singing at 1:28; she kicks it up another notch (a third, to be precise) at 1:45.

The Mamas + The Papas | Monday, Monday

“While awaiting the release of ”California Dreamin’,’ band member Denny Doherty was prodding songwriter John Phillips to come up with some new material,” (Songfacts). “Phillips said he would come back in the morning with ‘a song with universal appeal.’ Ignoring the sarcastic comments from the group members, Phillips came up with ‘Monday, Monday’ (1966). It’s about the lousy feeling that comes with the end of the weekend and beginning of another workweek.

This was the first Hot 100 chart-topper with a day in the week in the title, and the only one with ‘Monday.’ (‘Manic Monday’ by the Bangles and “Rainy Days And Mondays” by the Carpenters both stalled at #2.) … Denny Doherty, who sang lead on this song, thought very little of ‘Monday Monday’ when they recorded it. ‘Nobody likes Monday, so I thought it was just a song about the working man,’ he said. ‘Nothing about it stood out to me; it was a dumb f–kin’ song about a day of the week.’ As you can imagine, he was taken by surprise when the song became a huge hit. Doherty wasn’t alone in his incredulity: Mama Cass and Michelle Phillips didn’t like the song either, and John Phillips claimed he had no idea what the song meant.”

Starting in F# major, the tune features some brief harmonic sidesteps along the way, but doesn’t modulate in earnest until 1:41, when it shifts up to G# major.

The Brothers Johnson | The Real Thing

“Guitarist/vocalist George Johnson and bassist/vocalist Louis Johnson formed the band Johnson Three Plus One with older brother Tommy and their cousin Alex Weir while attending school in Los Angeles,” (AllMusic). “When they became professionals, the band backed such touring R&B acts as Bobby Womack and the Supremes. George and Louis Johnson later joined Billy Preston’s band, and wrote “Music in My Life” and “The Kids and Me” for him before leaving his group in 1973.”

After scoring hits with “I’ll Be Good to You,” “Stomp,” and “Strawberry Letter 23,” The group released the single “The Real Thing” in 1981, reaching #11 on the R&B charts.

“The Real Thing” starts in A minor, but prominently shifts to C# minor at 0:50 and again to E minor at 1:20 before returning to A minor at 1:35. More changes follow from there.