“Co-written by two of the most brilliant pop composers, Richard Page and Kenny Loggins, ‘Who’s Right, Who’s Wrong,’ is a masterpiece of West Coast music,” (FozFan.com). “This smooth, jazzy ballad was first recorded in 1979 by the group Pages on their stunning album, Future Street. Loggins, who was a guest on Pages’ take, included it on his 1979 album Keep The Fire with Michael Jackson and Page on backing vocals.” From a Rolling Stone review: “the new sound of Southern California: a sophisticated, diffuse, jazz-inflected pop rock performed by an augmented rock band in which guitar and keyboards share equal prominence” and “churning romantic atmosphere constructed around a matinee idol’s voice.”
Page, perhaps best known as the lead vocalist and bassist for Mr. Mister, lends plenty of supple, melodic bass lines to the track. Michael McDonald played keys and provided backup vocals; Paulinho da Costa was a contributor to the almost constantly varying percussion; Michael Brecker’s signature tenor sax sound was central to the track. But it was Michael Jackson — a few years before the mega-stardom of Thriller and contemporaneously with his breakthrough 1979 solo album Off the Wall — who might have been the track’s most surprising contributor. Loggins sings the verses, but outsources the choruses to Jackson, elevating MJ’s role to something closer to that of a co-lead vocalist.
After a start in G major, 0:44 brings a shift to Bb major; the chorus, starting at 1:12, is in D major. Many other shifts follow, including a big key change at 3:26, where vocals re-enter at the end Brecker’s solo section. The arrangement is so polished in some spots — particularly the instrumental sections (intro, solo, and outro) — that the sound seems somehow reminiscent of the legendary Steely Dan tune “Aja.”